Theodore L. Gerstle

Theodore L. GerstleDr

4.5(8 reviews)# 100, 166, Pasadena Drive, Fayette County, Lexington, KY 40503

Profile

Dr. Theodore L. Gerstle is a native of New York with strong roots in the state of Kentucky. Though he has a large extended Kentucky family, he was born and raised in Westchester, New York. He has a long history of service, beginning in childhood as he joined the Boy Scouts of America, ultimately achieving the rank of Eagle Scout. He received his Bachelors of Science in Engineering Management at The United States Military Academy at West Point, New York.

After Dr. Gerstle’s military commitment was complete, he decided that medicine was the best way to continue helping others. He entered University of Louisville’s School of Medicine, was elected the President of his class each year he was there. He was awarded multiple awards, including acceptance into the prestigious Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Society. When Dr. Gerstle completed medical school, he was chosen to speak as the distinguished graduate at the University of Louisville’s graduation ceremony.

After graduation from medical school, he moved to Boston to train in the Harvard Combined Plastic Surgery Residency program. Dr. Gerstle also specializes in treatment for migraine headaches. Whether choosing conservative treatments like nerve blocks, Botox, or surgery in hope for a cure of these debilitating headaches, he is excited to offer these skills to the Bluegrass.

Dr. Gerstle performs facial rejuvenation, breast surgery, body contouring, emergency repair of lacerations, reconstructive surgery of the head, neck, chest, and breast. He believes every patient is unique and provides personalized consultations to discuss the least invasive options to achieve tasteful, natural looking results, while utilizing a detailed and sensitive approach to patients of all ages.

Locations (1)

Lexington, KY

# 100, 166, Pasadena Drive, Fayette County, Lexington, KY 40503

Procedures (41)

ProcedureRank in US
#0
#1565
#1341
#1009
#2229
#2048
#1411
#1966
#2406
#1724
#1119
#0
#797
#1864
#0
#1213
#2053
#1211
#814
#0
#0
#0
#0
#684
#476
#1250
#2261
#602
#608
#563
#528
#398
#0
#325
#1208
#252
#405
#931
#1240
#271
#383

Reviews (8)

4.5

8 reviews

5
88%
4
0%
3
0%
2
13%
1
0%
5.0
May 8, 2025
I recently had a mommy makeover performed by Dr. Gerstle ,and I couldn’t be happier with my results! From the initial consultation to my post-op care, he and his team went above and beyond to make me feel comfortable and confident in my decision. His attention to detail and skill truly show in my results—I feel more like myself than I have in years! A special thank you to the nurse practitioner Katie and nurse Lauren, who were absolutely amazing throughout the entire process. Their kindness, patience, and expertise made such a difference in my experience. They were always available to answer my questions, provide reassurance, and ensure I was well taken care of. The entire staff was professional, compassionate, and truly top-notch. If you’re considering a procedure, I highly recommend Dr. Gerstle and his incredible team. Thank you all for everything!!🩷

Terra Durbin

5.0
Mar 27, 2025
I was so nervous when I went my initial consult (being that it would be the first elective surgery ever) to have a tummy tuck, Dr. Gerstle and Katie APRN were very informative answering all my questions about the procedure and what to expect that I knew I was in the BEST hands. The day of surgery everything went smoothly, nurse Lauren and Katie took great care of me afterwards. I have phenomenal results and my abs are so much stronger! I am so happy to have chose LPS!! Everyone there are top knotch an are genuinely so kind and caring. I continuously recommend them to everyone and will go to them for any of my plastic surgery needs❤️

C. Rose

5.0
Feb 15, 2025
I love this office. I adore Dr. Gerstle! So thoughtful of my feelings and insecurities. They are all so amazing!

Debbie C.

5.0
Dec 19, 2024
After spending a majority of my life with back pain and insecurities, I booked a free consultation at Lexington Plastic Surgery on a whim, expecting nothing to come of it. Dr. Gerstle was so down to earth and truly made me feel seen and understood. I went home that evening determined to make this breast reduction happen. Dr. Gerstle and his staff have been amazing every step of the way, always attentive and ready to answer any and all of my questions. My surgery and recovery was seamless. I just had my 1 month post-op check up today and couldn’t be happier. The back pain that had become a part of life has disappeared overnight, I haven’t had a single headache since (was used to about 3 a week), and I just feel so much more confident. Nov. 18th may have been a typical Monday for them, but it was life changing for me! I’m so glad curiosity got the best of me and led me to Lexington Plastic Surgery.

Heather Phillips

5.0
Aug 30, 2024
I can not say enough good things about Dr Gerstle and his team, I had already decided I was Getting a breast augmentation. I just Had to find the right Doctor and facility. I researched For awhile and when I found Dr Gerstle, I set Up a consult and immediately knew he was the one. This facility is 3 hours from my town, but it’s well worth driving for. He genuinely cares about his patients and likes to help people feel good about themselves. Him and his staff make you feel so comfortable! Even during surgery I had a great experience. Post surgery was great, no bruising at all and no issues. I’m two weeks post op now and doing great! They look great and natural, which is what I wanted. I highly Recommend him for any of your plastic surgery needs. I will Be a repeat patient :) Thank you Dr Gerstle for your amazing handiwork!

Gina Ferguson

5.0
Jul 18, 2024
Extremely pleased & ecstatic even with my surgery & results with Dr. Gerstle. He as well as his staff are wonderful, knowledgeable, caring and very pleasant. Very happy I went with Dr. Gerstle, he’s very good at what he does and through his work, helped me regain confidence. I would absolutely recommend him.

Whitney

2.0
Sep 4, 2021
I'll give them 2 stars because they are super nice. Too bad after my revision and wound opening (again) he completely ignored signs of infection. Went to a...

Marinda B.

5.0
Jan 18, 2019
Great plastic surgeon. Just got: neck lift, lower facelift, lower eyelid lift and fat grafting at the same time and the results are awesome. He has great...

Tammy F.